Fiscal decentralisation and state-level accountability — by Adebayo Afolabi

Every month, billions of naira are shared among Nigeria’s three tiers of government through the Federation Account Allocation Committee. The announcement focuses on how much each state receives, the deductions, and the fairness of the formula. What happens after the money reaches state accounts gets far less attention.

Between January and June 2026, states and the Federal Capital Territory received ₦4.65 trillion from FAAC. Lagos, Delta, Rivers, Akwa Ibom and Bayelsa took about 33 per cent of that total. State governments control much of the spending on primary healthcare, basic education, local roads and other services people rely on. The quality of these services tells us more about public spending than the size of any monthly allocation.

Each state sits in a different financial position. Lagos has a large commercial base and raises substantial revenue of its own. States with smaller economies have fewer ways to collect taxes and other income. The National Bureau of Statistics reported that the 36 states and the FCT generated a combined ₦5.15 trillion in internally generated revenue in 2025, up 40.93 per cent from ₦3.65 trillion in 2024. Lagos contributed about ₦1.77 trillion. Rivers recorded ₦428.42 billion and Enugu ₦406.77 billion. Yobe generated ₦16.01 billion, Ebonyi ₦17.18 billion and Sokoto ₦20.48 billion.

Enugu’s increase came largely from revenue raised by its ministries, departments and agencies, not from tax receipts alone. Higher IGR does not necessarily reflect a more productive local economy. Collections can improve through better administration even without more businesses, jobs or higher household incomes.

BudgIT’s analysis of state finances shows the heavy reliance on federal transfers. Of the 34 states it compared, 28 received more from FAAC in the first five months of 2026 than they generated internally in the whole of 2025. Those states took ₦2.64 trillion from FAAC in five months against a combined annual IGR of ₦1.387 trillion. FAAC’s share of total state revenue climbed from 68.7 per cent in 2022 to 73.3 per cent in 2025.

Federal allocations make sense. Differences in population, natural resources and commercial activity leave some states with a smaller revenue base. Transfers help fund public services and narrow the gap between richer and poorer parts of the country. The issue is that this dependence has not produced matching public scrutiny of how the money is spent.

Residents hear about billions arriving from FAAC and still see little change in their communities. Health centres stay poorly equipped. Schools remain overcrowded. Local roads keep deteriorating. In many places, basic services stay hard to reach even as government accounts fill up.

States chasing higher IGR also need caution. Arbitrary levies, multiple taxation and harassment of traders make life harder for residents and small businesses. Revenue growth should come from a more productive local economy, fairer tax systems and processes that make compliance easier.

Healthcare shows the gap between revenue and results most clearly. BudgIT’s State of States 2025 report found that states spent an average of just ₦3,483 per person on healthcare in 2024. They spent ₦816.64 billion of the ₦1.32 trillion budgeted for health — 61.9 per cent of the allocation.

A budget line is not the same as money spent. Money spent does not automatically deliver a working service. A primary health centre can appear in the budget and still lack medicines, equipment or enough staff. The same pattern appears in schools and roads. Announcing a project does little if the work is delayed, poorly done or left without funds for maintenance.

Big infrastructure projects draw more attention. A flyover, stadium or government building gives a governor something visible to commission. Keeping rural roads passable, stocking health centres with medicines and staffing public schools properly demand steady attention and steady spending. The less visible work is just as important to the people who rely on these services.

Debt adds more pressure. BudgIT recorded ₦2.11 trillion in debt-servicing costs across states in 2024, plus unpaid contractor, pension and gratuity arrears. Borrowing can fund infrastructure, but repayments shrink the money left for other services. Residents deserve to know what the loans paid for and why contractors and pensioners still wait.

Lagos and Enugu show different paths to higher revenue. Lagos benefits from a much larger formal economy. Enugu’s rise came substantially from MDA revenue. Other states can learn from their revenue collection methods, but the real test is the improvement in public services.

State Houses of Assembly carry a clear duty here. Legislators should examine budgets, check expenditure and act on the Auditor-General’s findings. The 2025 Subnational Audit Efficacy Index from the Paradigm Leadership Support Initiative highlights ongoing weaknesses in state audit institutions. Delayed reports and weak legislative oversight leave residents in the dark about how public funds are handled.

Local government finances need the same focus. Councils handle the services closest to people — local roads, markets, sanitation and primary healthcare. Their ability to deliver depends on receiving the funds meant for them and controlling how those funds are used.

In July 2024 the Supreme Court ruled that local government allocations should go directly to the councils rather than through the joint allocation system controlled by state governments. The ruling granted local governments financial autonomy, but direct access to allocations does not automatically translate into better services. Councils still have to publish their accounts, explain their spending and answer for projects that never appear.

Residents may know their local government receives an allocation each month, but that means little if they cannot see how the money is spent on projects and services in their communities. Without public oversight, autonomy simply shifts control from state governments to local councils, with little improvement in people’s lives.

Federal transfers will continue, especially for states with weaker economies. Every government that receives public money must still account for its use. State assemblies, audit bodies, the media and citizens all share the work of making spending more transparent.

The debate over revenue sharing often centres on how much each state receives, with little attention given to how the money is eventually spent. A state can raise more revenue, receive billions from FAAC and pass ambitious budgets without improving people’s lives in any meaningful way.

Public money should be measured by results: working health centres, properly staffed schools, maintained roads and services people can rely on. Until state and local governments are held to that standard, larger allocations will not automatically mean better living conditions.

Adebayo Afolabi is a Nigerian writer examining democracy, governance, and public policy in Africa.

blank
blank

Related Articles

Back to top button